St. Peter's United Church of Christ


Go to content

The Spirit Leads On

About Us > A Brief History > The Congregation

History - The Spirit Leads On "The Spirit Leads On"

The next decade and beyond was a crucial period in the life of St. Peter's Church.  The 1930's and the early 1940's were not only crucial in the history of St. Peter's, but also in the life of Elmhurst, the Evangelical Synod and the whole United States.  There were the years marked int he early 1930's by the "Great Depression" when many bsanks were closed and business declined and unemployment prevailed.  It was a difficult time for all institutions, and particularly for churches.  The church doors never closeed and the loyalty of committed Christians kept the church program operating.  It is in hard times that people often are led back to faith in God.

It was in this period that a great event in modern church history took place.  After years of preparatory negotiations, the Evangelical Synod of North America, to which St. Peter's belonged, entered into a merger with the Reformed Church in the United States, and out of this event came a stronger denomination, the Evangelical and Reformed Church.  St. Peter's Evangelical Church became St. Peter's Evangelical and Reformed Church.

The city of Elmhurst in 193 engaged in a great celebration of the centennial of the arrival of its first settlers.  Elmhurst was a growing and beautiful suburb.  The census of 1930 indicated a population of 14,085.

Then came the horror of World War II and the involvement of the United States in the war following the incident of Pearl Harbor.    All of these events had their effect on the life and work of St. Peter's Church.  After Pastor Chworowsky accepted a call from a church in the east, the Reverend Frederick Frankenfeld of Rochester, New York became available for consideration as pastor.    He was the minister of Salem Church in Rochester, the largest chruch in our denomination at the time, with a membership of three thousand.  He had served that congregation for twenty-four years with outstanding success and was recognized as being one of the denomination's outstanding preachers and leaders.  The pulpit committee of St. Peter's seized this opportunity and recommended Dr. Frankenfeld to our congregation on the basis of his record.  He was elected as pastor in early 1934 without ever preaching a guest sermon, and began his ministry in St. Peter's in the early summer.

Pastor Frankenfeld was a strong preacher.  He had a strong Sunday School, with organized classes, as was the custom of the time.  He was a strong advocate of Christian Stewardship and trained his people in the art of giving.  He cultivated an interest in the missionary and benevolent program of the church.  He was an acknowledged leader in his community, and also in the denominatin at large.  

Dr. Frankenfeld quickly won the affection of the people and they responed to his leadership.  He was first of all an administrator and organizer.  He began by organizing and systematizing the membership record.  A second task was that of bringing order into the financial situation of the church.  With a firm base of individual membership established, an envelope system finally became the one method of church support.  With these tools a well planned schedule made possible an orderly and early retirement of the church's debts.

For a long time the church had looked for additional land, especially for parking and also for eventual expansion of the church building.  Such an opportunity presented itself in 1942-43 and, under the vigorous promotion of the pastor, the corner property on Cottage Hill Avenue was purchased.  

In February of 1946, Dr. Frankenfeld surprised the congregation by announcing his resignation.  He felt that advancing years and the continued growth of the congregation made it imperative to make way for a younger man who could best meet the enlarging opportunities of the church.  It was with deep regret but with full understanding that the congregation accepted the resignation of its beloved pastor.


Light and Shadow

By August of 1946 the congregation had elected a new pastor.  He was Reverend Edwin J. A. Koch, a graduate of Elmhurst College and Eden Seminary.  Dr. Koch's years in Elmhurst were in the post-World War II period, marked by a rapid upswing in the economy which gave rise to an increasing prosperity.  And in 1949 an opportunity presented itself to purchase a second piece of property facing Cottage Hill Avenue and Wilder Park.  The congregation mortgaged its new church in order to buy this additional frontage.  The land is today a part of  our west parking lot.

In the ongoing life of the church there was a steady flow of new members.  At this time the demand for German services had declined to the point that such services were held only once a month.  There was continuous discussion and pressure for additional facilities for the Sunday School.  The matter of a new parsonage was a controversail issue.  The pastor and others often lamented a certain lack of spirit and of loyalty on the part of a large portion of the congregation, unable to rise to the new challenges presented.

It was strange that moves toward a new education building, a new parsonage, and an assistant to the pastor always met with divided response.  There was unfortunately an undercurrent of dissatisfaction with the pastoral leadershipm, which manifested itself in sub-surface and also in overt ways.  A division of the congregation was evident.  In 1953 a group of members broke away from St. Peter's Church to petition for a new congregation.  Out of this situation Bethel Church in Elmhurst came into being in June of 1953.  Yet strangely enough there was a steady flow of new members, but in spite of it the total membership through all these years hovered at the 900 mark.  

In October of 1956, Pastor Koch presented his resignatin and accepted a call to Bethany Church in Detroit, MI.  At this time in 1956 the church decided to drop its German services entirely.


Onward and Forward

The decade of the 1960's was one of restlessness and change in the American church life.  It was a time when the church was relatively popular and to be a church member was the thing to do.  This period was followed by one of ferment and unrest, sparked by economic uncertainty and the nation's involvement in Vietnam.  It was a time of protest and revolution, of activisim and an emphasis on "relevance", of  emphasis on "doing" to the neglect of inwardness.  In this time of change St. Peter's was again faced with the need to find new leadership.

After diligent search the Committee on Church and Ministry recommended the Reverend Robert J. Young.  He was elected by the congregation and installed as pastor on September 15, 1957.  Dr. Young was a graduate of Elmhurst College and Eden Seminary.

Back to content | Back to main menu